Shilling for hits
On the whole, theserverside.com is a pretty decent site. It has some mildly interesting articles, the product announcements are relevant, and the editorialising is kept to a pleasant minimum. The technical content is also surprisingly relevant and topical.
The whole thing however is let down by regular baiting and shilling by some users/authors, who seem to go through moments of panic when the comment count drops for a few successive stories.
So what to do in this case? Why, say something controversial! Over the years, TSS has pretty much identified both of the ‘hot’ topics (ie, JBoss, and opensource) as great obsessive fanatic breeding grounds. So when things flag, you can be sure you’ll have some link to a highly dubious article saying one or the other is great (nobody is offended when either is portrayed as not THAT great, interestingly enough).
A particularly funny/offensive example of this was a ‘is JBoss ready for the enterprise’ advert run there a couple of weeks ago. This is supposedly an objective evaluation of said product by some random guy who is trying to determine whether it’s good enough to use, based on some dodgy metrics. Fair enough, nothing too odd about that. The fun bit is when you realise that the author happens to be the CEO of a company that does training and consulting for open source products. Gosh, and he found that some opensource product is in fact ready for the enterprise?! This is NOTEWORTHY to him? I mean really, shouldn’t it be sufficient for him to say ‘my business is all about open source in the enterprise’ for the rest of us to realise that he thinks it’s a good idea?
While much of the blame should be placed on the genius who authorised this offensive article, tss users should also shoulder much of the responsibility.
Cameron, please please stop baiting these poor people. It’s a well documented fact that Gavin Fleury has claimed the deeper shades of purple for his exclusive use lately. The poor guy’s head will at some point explode if you keep taunting him so subtly.
See, one has to understand something about these jboss kids. They’re very, very sensitive. Their favourite movie is When Harry Met Sally. They cry when they hear sad songs, and they blow up when you say their favourite toy isn’t your favourite toy. So why keep baiting them like this? I mean, it’s fun and all, but the novelty value of torturing a bunch of kids wears off fairly quickly. So please, let’s just ignore them and stop their tedious yapping.
It’s pretty sad that TSS regularly lowers its tone by such postings. Perhaps they have some kind of freakish javalobby envy syndrome, and aspire to to scale those admirable heights of crapulence, a dubious goal at the best of times.
September 9th, 2004 at 11:18 am
At least they don’t shill for hits by posting “Misty May and Kerri Walsh Roll Around in the Sand”
September 9th, 2004 at 11:53 am
And this is supposed to be a bile?! Slow summer, I guess…
September 9th, 2004 at 12:11 pm
My main problem with TSS is the quality of the editing (or lack there of). It appears that they don’t have anybody whose job is to look over the articles for spelling and grammar mistakes before they go live. Nobody is perfect, especially when you consider that TSS features articles by writers from all ove the world. Print newspapers and magazines have people called “editors”.. shouldn’t TSS?
September 9th, 2004 at 12:14 pm
Not one mention of “turds/turdburglers/poopoo/unmentionable tugging/poopy grins/scat”. :( We are witnessing here the transformation of Bile Blog to Coffee Talk with Hani. Anyhow, still a somewhat interesting. Is Hani taking anti-psychotics? I actually went to TSS yesterday and read up on that book Effective Enterprise with Ted Neward. So many misspellings. (Josh Block?) and _____1329??? what is that? And did I see JVN twice? Just CORBA with angle brackets? I’m beginning to miss Josh Bloch’s writing style quite a bit. No offense to Ted but whoever interviewed him did him a disservice. Doesn’t appear very original either. “.NET and java all the same”. EJB’s suck. *sigh*.
September 9th, 2004 at 12:53 pm
Hot grits and Natalie Portman!
In Soviet Russia, THE SERVERSIDE BILES YOU!
September 9th, 2004 at 1:55 pm
Yeah I’d stick with Java Ranch over TSS. I think TSS has been hypocritical with the JBoss thing. First they announce that they are disassociating with JBoss, now they’re putting front page news releases about JBoss progress, etc.
September 9th, 2004 at 2:07 pm
Even more funny if you consider that it was JBoss who canceled the business relationship, not TSS…
September 9th, 2004 at 2:36 pm
Sounds like a high-school “who dumped whom” soap opera ;-)
September 9th, 2004 at 3:37 pm
But JBoss is GROOVY!
September 9th, 2004 at 5:08 pm
Just for completeness:
tugging
unmentionables
September 9th, 2004 at 5:30 pm
or the movie “He said. She said”
September 9th, 2004 at 8:12 pm
….the irony of seeing the bile blog commenting on another site being a site whore for having controversial topics is delicious.
September 9th, 2004 at 8:58 pm
Irony .. you need it or you get anemic ..
September 10th, 2004 at 2:06 am
keep on the valium hani it seems to be working
September 10th, 2004 at 10:51 am
me think hani is gettin in touch with his inner class
moo!